How does YouTube remove policy violative election-related content?
YouTube’s Community Guidelines provide clear guidance on what is not allowed on our platform, and we remove content that violates these policies.
Policies specific to elections misinformation include:
-
Voter Suppression - Prohibits content aiming to mislead voters about the time, place, means, or eligibility requirements for voting, or false claims that could materially discourage voting. e.g. a video telling viewers they can vote through fake methods like texting their vote to a particular number.
-
Candidate Eligibility - Prohibits content that advances false claims related to the technical eligibility requirements for current political candidates and sitting elected government officials to serve in office. Eligibility requirements considered are based on applicable national law, and include age, citizenship, or vital status.
-
Incitement to interfere with democratic processes - Prohibits content encouraging others to interfere with democratic processes. This includes obstructing or interrupting voting procedures.
Community Guidelines that apply to all forms of content, including elections, include:
-
Harassment Policy - Content that threatens individuals such as election workers, candidates, or voters isn’t allowed under our Harassment & cyberbullying policies.
-
Hate Speech Policy - Content that promotes violence or hatred against individuals or groups based on certain attributes isn’t allowed under our Hate speech policies. This includes, for example, content that shows a political rally attendee dehumanizing a group based on a protected attribute, such as race, religion, or sexual orientation.
-
Manipulated Content - Prohibits content that has been technically manipulated or doctored in a way that misleads users (usually beyond clips taken out of context) and may pose a serious risk of egregious harm. For example, footage that has been technically manipulated to make a candidate for public office falsely claim they’re dropping out of the race.
-
Misattributed Content - Content that may pose a serious risk of egregious harm by falsely claiming that old footage from a past event is from a current event isn’t allowed under our Misinformation policies. For example, a video that shows a head of state condoning a violent conflict that he or she never actually condoned.
-
Violent or Graphic Content Policy - Content that encourages others to commit violent acts, including acts targeting election workers, candidates, or voters isn’t allowed under our Violent or graphic content policies.
-
Impersonation Policy - Content that’s intended to impersonate a person or channel, such as a political candidate or their political party, isn’t allowed under our Impersonation policy.
-
Spam, Deceptive Practices, and Scams Policies - Prohibits misleading content meant to take advantage of YouTube users.
-
External Links Policy - Content that contains external links to material that would violate our policies and can cause a serious risk of egregious harm, like misleading or deceptive content relating to an election, hate speech targeting protected groups, or harassment targeting election workers, candidates, or voters. This can include clickable URLs, verbally directing users to other sites in a video, and other forms of link-sharing.
Sometimes, videos that might otherwise violate our policies may stay on YouTube if the content contains Educational, Documentary, Scientific or Artistic (EDSA) context.
To help determine whether a video might qualify for an EDSA exception, we look at multiple factors, including the video title, descriptions, and the context provided in the video’s audio or imagery. For example, something that is more likely to get an EDSA exception is content where an individual makes a false claim that individuals who are older than a certain age aren’t allowed to vote in a democratic election and also clarifies in the video, audio, title or description that this claim is false.
Addressing AI-generated election misinformation
Challenges posed by generative AI have been an ongoing area of focus for YouTube, but we know AI introduces new risks that bad actors may try to exploit during an election. AI can be used to generate content that has the potential to mislead viewers���particularly if they’re unaware that the video has been altered or is synthetically created. To better address this concern and inform viewers when the content they’re watching is altered or synthetic, we’ll start to introduce the following updates:
-
Creator Disclosure: Creators will be required to disclose when they’ve created altered or synthetic content that’s realistic, including using AI tools. This will include election content.
-
Labeling: We’ll label realistic altered or synthetic election content that doesn’t violate our policies, to clearly indicate for viewers that some of the content was altered or synthetic. For elections, this label will be displayed in both the video player and the video description, and will surface regardless of the creator, political viewpoints or language.
Mock showing label added to the video player and description panel.
Getting ahead of emerging issues
Removing policy-violative content as quickly as possible requires that we are aware of emerging threats in addition to content we already prohibit. To help stay ahead of emerging issues before they reach or become widespread on our platform, we have developed extensive processes to give our teams visibility into this area.
In 2018, we formed an Intelligence Desk, an internal team that monitors and detects new trends surrounding inappropriate content and problematic behaviors, to help address them early.
Additionally, we work closely with Google’s Threat Analysis Group (TAG) to identify coordinated influence operations on YouTube and terminate their channels and accounts. This includes government-backed hacking looking to interfere in electoral processes. Through TAG, we share intelligence, best practices, and threat information with law enforcement and industry partners. TAG discloses in their monthly Bulletin information about coordinated influence operation campaigns terminated on Google platforms, including YouTube.
How does YouTube raise election information from authoritative sources?
For news and information topics such as elections and civic engagement, accuracy and authoritativeness are key. This is why we incorporated the notion of “authoritativeness” in our recommendation system. When users search for or watch elections content on YouTube, our recommendation system prominently surfaces authoritative content in search results, the homepage and “Watch Next” panel.
We use a number of signals to determine authoritativeness, including the relevance and freshness of the content, as well as the expertise of the source, to determine what content you see in our officially labeled news surfaces. Additionally, we use external raters and experts to provide critical input and guidance on the accuracy of videos. These evaluators hail from around the world and are trained through a set of detailed, publicly available rating guidelines .
News features help raise election-related news from authoritative sources
Availability depending on geographical region
Product features that help raise news from authoritative sources across YouTube include:
A watch page for news content on YouTube
*Mock Display. For Illustration Purposes Only
To help viewers explore different sides of a news story and form their own opinion of the world, we launched a watch page that brings together a collection of news content from authoritative and diverse sources on YouTube.
Breaking news on the homepage
When a major breaking news event happens, we want to make sure that viewers are aware and can easily access authoritative information. In those cases the Breaking News shelf appears directly on the homepage. It features relevant videos from authoritative news sources about news events of national importance.
*Mock display. For illustration purposes only.
Top news in Search Results
When viewers proactively search for news-related topics, they will often see a Top News section near the top of search results, which displays relevant results from authoritative sources.
*Mock display. For illustration purposes only.
Top news on the homepage
When viewers proactively search for news-related topics, they will often see a Top News section near the top of the homepage, which displays relevant results from authoritative sources.
*Mock display. For illustration purposes only.
Informational panels provide users with additional context to help them make informed decisions about content on our platform
Developing news information panel
In developing news situations, links to text-based news articles from authoritative sources may display above relevant search results, as quality video may not be immediately available.
*Mock display. For illustration purposes only.
Publisher funding information panel
To provide more context about news sources, funding information may be displayed for government or publicly funded publishers.
*Images, headlines, and sources are simulated in order to illustrate this feature.
Topical context information panel
To provide more context about topics prone to misinformation, such as voting by mail, an information panel may be displayed at the top of search results or under a video to show basic background info sourced from authoritative sources
*Images, headlines, and sources are simulated in order to illustrate this feature.
During key civics and elections moments, we take additional efforts to raise information from authoritative sources
In addition to our always-on product features that raise information from authoritative sources on our platform, we may launch additional features during key civics and election moments.
Candidate information panels
For some elections, additional information, like party affiliation, may be provided for all federal candidates. In addition, candidates with an official YouTube channel may have their channel pinned for those specific elections.
Our candidates for head of state are eligible to receive the enlarged card on the right.
*Images, headlines, and sources are simulated in order to illustrate this feature.
Voting information panels
When viewers search for voting-related topics, links to authoritative information on "how to register to vote" and "how to vote" may display, pointing to authoritative sources powered by non-partisan, third-party data partners like Democracy Works.
*Images, headlines, and sources are simulated in order to illustrate this feature.
Elections results information panels
When viewers search for election results or watch any videos related to the elections, a link to Google’s “Election Results” feature, powered by authoritative third parties, like the Associated Press, may display.
*Images, headlines, and sources are simulated in order to illustrate this feature.
Voter reminders
Throughout the election cycle, we may provide viewers links to timely, authoritative information about the voting process directly on the homepage, such as “how to register to vote”, “how to vote”, and “how to volunteer to be a poll worker”.
*Mock display. For illustration purposes only.
How does YouTube reward and support creators – including news and political creators, and candidates across the political spectrum?
Our business is unique among platforms because for over 15 years, we have had a revenue-sharing model, the YouTube Partner Program (YPP), and we send checks to eligible creators every month.
We view monetization on our platform as a privilege. Creators must be accepted into YPP to be eligible to monetize their content.
A key eligibility requirement for YPP is to follow YouTube monetization policies, which include our Community Guidelines, Terms of Service, and Google AdSense program policies. These policies apply to a creator’s channel as a whole, not just to individual videos. And we review each applicant’s channel before approving.
Over the past few years, we’ve taken steps to strengthen the requirements for monetization so that spammers, impersonators, and other bad actors can’t hurt the system or take advantage of creators meeting our eligibility requirements.
Because of this unique model, we have a natural, long-term incentive to live up to our responsibility. Advertisers, viewers, creators, and media partners do not want to be associated with harmful content.
The YouTube Partner Program supports political creators and candidates
Through the YouTube Partner Program, creators — including news and political creators, and candidates across the political spectrum — can access a greater suite of YouTube features and resources, helping them to more effectively reach viewers, deepen connections with their audience, and sustain and protect their business or platforms. These include:
Dedicated Partnerships Team - Dedicated Strategic Partner Managers work across the political spectrum to optimize presence on YouTube, reach viewers, and engage with their community.
Revenue Opportunities - Alternative monetization features help candidates sustain their platform.
Political Advertising on YouTube
We have a number of different policies in place for different types of content across Google and YouTube that can relate to political advertising. We enforce all of these guidelines consistently and without regard to a video’s political viewpoint. You can find political ads shown through Google via our Political Ads Transparency Report.
Google Ads policies and YouTube policies work together to ensure a safe, positive experience for our users, creators, and advertisers
Google has a number of policies to support a healthy digital advertising ecosystem, including political content. These policies govern the content that is shown in advertisements across Google, which includes YouTube. More information on these policies can be found here.
Posting either an ad or content on YouTube will define which policies apply
As part of Google, all advertising on YouTube must comply with Google’s Advertising policies. In addition, YouTube has monetization policies that govern what content can be monetized by creators. Put another way, these policies govern which content these ads can run against. One example of content that will result in a “limited or no ads” state is content that focuses on shaming an individual or group or that makes personal attacks, slander, or defamation.
The distinct policies from Google and YouTube work together to ensure a safe and positive experience for our users, creators, and advertisers.
| Ads on Youtube | Content on Youtube | |
|---|---|---|
| Google Ads Policies |  |
|
| YT Community Guidelines | |
|
| YT Monetization Policies | |
Tools and Resources
From the YT Blog
On the 2024 election:
On our recent election integrity policy update:
On the 2022 midterms:
On the 2020 election: